Lula Wins a Fourth Term. Bolsonaro Won't Accept It.
Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva was elected president of Brazil for a fourth time on 25 October, winning 51.8 percent of the vote against 48.2 percent for Senator Flávio Bolsonaro in the runoff. Bolsonaro, like his father, former president Jair Bolsonaro, who is in prison and banned from running until 2030, refused to recognize the result and announced that he would ask the courts to annul the vote.
Three weeks ago, in the first round on 4 October, no one predicted this outcome. Twelve candidates competed in the first round, and Bolsonaro received 47 percent of the valid votes while Lula received 45 percent, a difference of approximately 2.2 million votes. Most polls had predicted a different result, and Lula himself admitted he had been convinced he would win outright in the first round. Since Brazil's military dictatorship ended in 1985, no candidate who finished second in the first round had ever gone on to become president. Lula began rebuilding his campaign. He went after younger voters and got many of his supporters onto the streets. He presented the race as a question of national sovereignty, arguing that a Bolsonaro government would allow U.S. interference in Brazil. His efforts paid off where it mattered most. He won São Paulo and Rio de Janeiro, the two largest cities in Brazil, even though he lost both states, and he reversed his first-round defeat in the city of Rio.
Neither candidate was very popular. The campaign focused on the rising cost of living and crime. Bolsonaro campaigned as tough on crime and promised to lower food prices, while Lula relied on expensive government incentives to win over undecided voters. Both camps faced corruption suspicions involving relatives or allies. For most of the last two years, Lula's disapproval ratings were higher than his approval ratings. Lula himself even admitted in 2024 that his government had done very little to earn the support of the people who voted for him.
Now there is a dispute over what happened on election day itself. Three minutes before polls were due to close, Supreme Court Justice Cristiano Zanin ordered them to stay open for two more hours. Both sides had asked for this extension. Lula's campaign cited problems with buses taking voters to polls in São Paulo and Salvador, while Bolsonaro's. campaign cited heavy rain in the south of Brazil, his strongest region. This caused confusion. In some polling stations, the machines had already been switched off and could not be turned back on, and some volunteers were unsure whether to stay at their posts. Bolsonaro accused "Lula's friends on the Supreme Court" of changing the rules, pointing to the fact that Zanin was once Lula's lawyer.
Bolsonaro's argument appears weak. His own campaign requested the same extension as Lula's. According to the head of Brazil's electoral court, the two-hour extension did not affect the result. Paulo Sotero of the Wilson Center's Brazil Institute also told CNN that the extension "was not an irregularity." On top of this, two extra hours cannot explain a difference of 4.4 million votes. Brazil has used electronic voting since the 1990s, and no significant fraud has ever been found under this system.
Bolsonaro's refusal to concede is still worrying. Like his father in 2022, he is refusing to accept the result, and analysts warn that this could lead to protests. Jair Bolsonaro is currently in prison and barred from running until 2030, which is why his son was the candidate.
The election also matters beyond Brazil. It breaks the recent trend of candidates aligned with Donald Trump winning across Latin America, and it leaves Latin America's two most populous countries, Brazil and Mexico, with left-of-centre governments.
During the campaign, relations between Brazil and the United States were tense. Brazil's government called for an investigation into alleged U.S. funding of far-right causes inside Brazil. With a GDP of around $2.6 trillion, making it Latin America's largest economy, Brazil is likely to keep its distance from Washington despite President Trump's tariffs. In his victory speech, which also referred to Trump's military action in Venezuela, Lula said that Brazil would not accept being "anyone's backyard".
This is also the latest chapter in one of the most unusual political careers of modern times. A labour leader in the 1970s and co-founder of the Workers' Party (PT), Lula lost three presidential elections before finally winning in 2002 and 2006. His successor, Dilma Rousseff, was impeached in 2016. Then in 2018, Lula was jailed on corruption charges. He was released after 580 days in prison, and Brazil's Supreme Court later annulled his convictions after messages showed that the judge in his case had been biased. Lula then defeated Jair Bolsonaro in the October 2022 election. Now he has defeated Bolsonaro's son. With this victory, Lula becomes the first president of Brazil to win four terms, and he did it just days before turning 81. Along with Donald Trump and Nicaragua's Daniel Ortega, he is one of the oldest leaders in the Americas. Winning the election will be easier than governing. When his new term begins on 5 January 2027, he will be leading a divided country, with roughly half supporting him and roughly half against him.
Gustavo Gimenez (Year 13)




Comments